Oct 14, 2013; San Diego, CA, USA; General view of a referee flag on the field during the second half of the San Diego Chargers game against the Indianapolis Colts at Qualcomm Stadium. The Chargers won 19-9. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

Dolphins Can't Overcome Ghost Penalties

It’s hard to play in the NFL on the road and even harder when that road trip is in the stadium of a division rival.  Yet for three times a year teams face their enemies on foreign turf.  Playing against one of the best teams in the NFL for the past two decades makes it even harder.  Of course you can prepare for a team and game plan for a chance at victory.  You can even prepare for the weather curve ball that Mother Nature throws at you on a whim.  What you can’t prepare for is bad officiating.

Yesterday the officiating was bad.  No, it wasn’t bad it was downright atrocious.  While there is no guarantee that New England wouldn’t have won yesterday’s game without the penalties as Miami did just fine shooting themselves in the foot, it is safe to say that the penalties did make it much easier.

First there comes the first half 21 yard pass interference on Jimmy Wilson.  The 3rd and six play extended into Miami territory from the New England 46 placing the ball at the Miami 33.  Six plays later New England kicked a field goal to get on the board before half-time.  The problem?  Jimmy Wilson was in better position on the play than the intended receiver and played the ball perfectly.  The referee who was on top of the play never threw the flag but the line judge across the field who was much further away from the play did.  It was clearly a non-PI.


The Dolphins managed to overcome the poor call and kept the Patriots to a FG but that would not be the case when the 2nd half began.

Most in the media and fans at home will tell you everything changed with the Caleb Sturgis missed FG on Miami’s first possession of the 2nd half.  It definitely changed the momentum but the refs were not quite done yet.

After two big series for New England (which is where Miami lost both the lead and any confidence they had) the game would be tied 17-17 following two NE TD’s in the span of about two minutes.  Miami seemed to be ready to get some of their steam back when other factors took the game over once and for all.

Still tied at 17 late in the 3rd quarter Tom Brady threw a deep pass to TE Rob Gronkowski.  Gronkowski was in triple coverage and the ball was batted down.  As the Dolphins began to leave the field a flag was thrown and Dimitri Patterson was called for holding on the play.  The Patriots would end the 3rd quarter with a field goal to give them a 20-17 lead.

On the next Patriot drive following a Ryan Tannehill interception (Wallace needs to learn to fight for balls) the Patriots faced a first down and 10 from their own 36 yard line when Paul Soliai was flagged for illegal hands to the face.  Unfortunately replay showed Soliai’s head being shoved up and back with a hand to his face which wasn’t called.  The Pats moved up five yards.  Hardly critical at the time but it moved the ball out to the 41.  Then several plays later with the Patriots driving all hell broke loose.

QB Tom Brady was sacked and stripped of the ball.  The ball landed in front and to the left of DE Olivier Vernon who reached for the ball brushing it with his fingertips.  The ball shot about 15 yards downfield where the Patriots recovered but a flag on Vernon for illegally batting the ball brought the ball back to the original line of scrimmage and then five yards forward and was an automatic first down.  The call itself has been highly contested and debated by both fans and media but truth is it’s too hard to tell if Vernon deliberately attempted to push the ball away from a Patriot player.

Replays of the video are rather inclusive given the fact that Vernon did not punch at the ball and was fully extended when his hand reached for it.  Intentional or not the call was not warranted.  Even in full speed it is impossible to see any deliberate of malicious intent to swat the ball downfield.  Had it been clear then it would have been the right call but nothing supports than visually.  In other words it’s a case of interpretation by the referee who threw the flag and it changed the outcome of the game.

With a new set of downs and not facing a 3rd and 35 Tom Brady easily led his team into the endzone for a ten point lead with six minutes left.  At that point it appeared the Dolphins gave in and said forget it.  They didn’t play with much passion or determination after the face and despite driving down field one last time for a field goal attempt that was blocked the Dolphins seemed destined to lose the game.

Did the referees change the course of the game?  They didn’t decide it but they did influence the game by giving the Patriots extra opportunities on very suspect calls.  In addition they failed on several occasions to call penalties on the Patriot secondary after clear arm-bar pass interference and holds against Cameron Wake.  Regardless in the end, it was the Dolphins that blew the lead giving up 14 points unanswered to allow the Patriots to tie and eventually another ten to put the game away.

Still, it’s interesting to debate the type of influence the referees can have on the outcome or the momentum of a football game with a series of bad calls and bad judgements.  There is a time to let the players play the game but that has to be both ways…not just one.  Yesterday, it really looked like the Dolphins were playing more than just the Patriots in the 2nd half.  They played the Patriots, their own ineptitude, and the guys hired to make sure the game was played fair….at least in part.

Next Dolphins Game View full schedule »
Sunday, Sep 77 Sep1:00New England PatriotsBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Miami Dolphins NFL

  • Mario Ambrosio

    Rishard Matthews catch called out of bounds………Philbin said he thought about challenging the call but figured he’d lose the challenge anyway….probably right.

    • 1sb1

      Thought another angle might show an additional required body part in bounds–but we never saw another angle on replay. The way the Dolphins ill-manage the clock and burn time outs, I thought they should have taken the chance and challenged that one for sure.

      • Mario Ambrosio

        If you watch the replay slowly, you can see Matthews right shoe touch the field….

        • Mario Ambrosio

          Bright orange tip of shoe……

  • Chris Logel

    I agree, the calls were awful, but it reminded me of another deficiency that Miami has. If a play is close, good teams will sprint up to the ball and get a snap away before the head coach can gather enough information to make an informed decision whether or not to challenge the play, Miami seems not that interested in doing that. It is very frustrating.

  • Lee

    Excellent points! The Dolphins certainly shot themselves in the foot with the bad o-line play in the 2nd half and bad play calling, but having to overcome such a series of brutally bad calls (all leading to Pats points) was just too much for a team like the Dolphins, who frankly are just not quite good enough. Another key questionable no-call leading to points was the long completion to Dobson who appeared to push off on Patterson to catch an underthrown Brady ball in the 3rd quarter. Very frustrating to watch.

  • Chad Ronnebaum

    I would say this is the most suspect game I have ever seen done. However, I do recall in the Ravens game there were a couple of bogus pass interference calls on the Dolphins that helped the Ravens get back into it. Is there anywhere that we can track which officials are calling the Dolphins game and do a statistical analysis of how often they are making “judgement” calls? With all the pro-football focus out there on the players. We should have site that list the number of penalties called on a given team by a given Ref. If there is a Ref that appears to be throwing more flags it makes me wonder if he did not buy a car from Norman Braman, I am just saying Refs calling holding in under 5 yards when the pats player falls down as well a ref throwing a flag from a vantage point he can’t see from really seems very very odd to me. I can understand a missed call here and there. But making calls on things that did not happen or you can’t see?